What Behavioral Issues Impede Seamless Health Data Exchange?

In today’s rapidly evolving healthcare landscape, the ability to exchange health data seamlessly is paramount for improving patient outcomes and enhancing operational efficiencies. Despite significant legislative and technological advancements, behavioral challenges within the healthcare industry continue to obstruct effective data exchange. The 21st Century Cures Act of 2016 laid the groundwork for transforming health data exchange by mandating that certified EHR systems support data access, exchange, and utilization via standardized FHIR APIs. Effective from January 1, 2023, this requirement aims to ensure a more transparent and efficient data-sharing ecosystem. However, while compliance with these technical standards is improving, behavioral adherence remains problematic.

Certified developers have responded by publishing API documentation and earning their place on the Certified Health IT Product List. Additionally, CMS regulations require regulated payers to adopt these API technologies for interactions with payers, providers, and patients. These steps collectively seek to create a more cohesive, integrated healthcare environment.

Behavioral Barriers to API Utilization

The greatest obstacles to seamless health data exchange are rooted in behavior rather than technical limitations. Many API users find that the necessary documentation is either difficult to access or not user-friendly, complicating efforts to implement the required technologies effectively. These issues often lead to confusion and delays in integrating APIs into workflow systems, stymying the expected benefits of standardized data exchange. Key impediments include inadequate access to API documentation, restrictive fee structures, and intellectual property requirements that significantly deviate from the regulatory framework.

Additionally, some certified API developers impose prohibitive fees and contractual terms to control API access, disregarding regulatory prohibitions against such practices. This creates a financial and operational burden for healthcare providers and patients eager to utilize these technologies, thus restricting the potential for broader integration and adoption.

Accessibility Issues and Compliance Violations

Another significant barrier involves identifying and connecting to available EHR systems. Many systems are hidden behind generic API endpoints, rendering it difficult for third-party developers to establish connections with healthcare entities. This obstruction not only impedes the practical implementation of these technologies but also increases frustration among developers and users alike.

Moreover, provider organizations sometimes impose unnecessary agreements, such as requiring patient-access API developers to sign HIPAA Business Associate Agreements without regulatory necessity. This creates additional hurdles and confusion, deviating from the intended patient-centric model of data accessibility. Failing to provide timely responses to electronic health information access requests further compounds these challenges. The lack of adherence to required timelines for addressing access denials undermines the foundational goals of transparency and efficiency.

Oversight and Enforcement Challenges

Behavioral non-compliance with certification requirements poses a systemic risk to the broader health IT landscape. Certified API developers who engage in practices that inhibit access, exchange, or use of electronic health information could be committing information blocking, which is strictly prohibited under current regulations unless justified by law or specific exceptions. Non-compliance risks not only deteriorate trust in health IT but also hinder the adoption of new technologies, increase operational costs, and ultimately lead to poorer patient outcomes. Effective oversight and enforcement are essential to mitigate these risks, with the ASTP/ONC taking steps to enhance compliance monitoring and enforce relevant policies.

Partnerships with HHS components, such as the Office of Inspector General, play a crucial role in this oversight. The OIG holds the authority to impose significant penalties on non-compliant developers, further underscoring the importance of adhering to established protocols.

Future Steps and Educational Initiatives

Recognizing the persistent behavioral challenges, ASTP/ONC is committed to enhancing oversight mechanisms and providing robust educational resources to guide compliant practices. A rigorous review process for API documentation and continued monitoring of compliance trends are central to these efforts. To foster a greater understanding of the importance of API standards and encourage behavioral compliance, ASTP/ONC plans to host quarterly virtual roundtables and additional webinars focused on key certification requirements. These initiatives aim to bridge the gap between technical standards and practical implementation by addressing common behavioral pitfalls.

Enhanced educational content, such as fact sheets and API guidelines, will further support these efforts. By demystifying the requirements and offering clear, actionable guidance, ASTP/ONC hopes to facilitate a smoother transition to compliant and effective health data exchange practices.

The Path Forward

The vision outlined by the 21st Century Cures Act aims to create an advanced, innovative health IT environment that genuinely benefits the public. Although considerable progress has been made in building the necessary tech infrastructure, true success hinges on overcoming behavioral barriers that hinder seamless data exchange. These hurdles include resistance to change, lack of awareness, and varying levels of commitment within the industry.

To tackle these issues, stringent oversight is essential. This means consistently monitoring and evaluating health IT systems to ensure they meet high standards of functionality and security. Additionally, targeted education programs are crucial. By educating healthcare professionals and stakeholders about the benefits and proper use of health IT, the industry can foster a more cooperative environment.

A commitment to continuous improvement is also vital. The healthcare sector must stay updated with technological advancements and adapt practices to optimize interoperability. Regularly reviewing and refining processes will help in addressing issues as they arise, making health IT more integrative over time. By focusing on these key areas, the healthcare industry can break down the barriers to data exchange and fully realize the potential of health IT interoperability, ultimately delivering greater value to the public.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest

Keep up to date with the latest news and events

Paperplanes Paperplanes Paperplanes
Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later